In the poem, "All Watched Over By Machines" by Richard Brautigan can be seen as anti-technology. He seems to be writing with a lot of sarcasm, especially in the verses that are in parenthesis. For example, the first stanza states "I like to think/ (right now, please!)”. This statement feels like a forced request. Not something that the poet would actually like to happen. The poem also produces pictures in the reader’s mind that seem to be impossible in existing. For example, in the second stanza, verses five and six, it says, “where deer stroll peacefully/ past computers”. This created more of an image of a devastation of civilization and technology. Sort of how it is pictured in the movie “I am Legend” where it is seen that antelope and deer roam around New York City. It is not something that you would expect.
At the same time, this poem can be seen as pro- technology. The poem can be seen to have a tranquil tone to it. The poet speaks, in the first stanza, of nature and technology living harmoniously together. The simile the Brautigan uses at the end of the stanza, “like pure water/ touching clear sky” gives the reader a greater sense of the calmness between the two worlds. Usually a reading will have at least clouds in the sky if there is an issue underlying but you do not see this in the poem at all.
I think that the poem, although on the surface very pro technology, is really anti-technology. I think Brautigan is predicting or foreshadowing what is going to happen with the technology in the future. The fact that technology will be filling land fills and that nature and animals will have to adapt to live around it harmoniously and that there is nothing that can be done by the animals. That is why he does not state that humans will have to live with it but the trees, the forests, and the animals, which have no say as to where these items go.